Another reason it’s hard to make a Top 20 list of games is how to assess older games. Have you ever, as an adult, seen cartoons you loved as a kid? There’s some timeless classics, Looney Tunes and the like, but I was channel hopping on satellite TV a while back, and found a MASK cartoon.
I loved MASK. I’d get up at some ungodly hour on a Saturday morning when everyone else was still asleep to watch it. I’d endure Timmy Mallett and the Wide Awake Club for MASK. Later on I realised it was just an extended advert for action figures, but even so had a bit of a soft spot for it. On watching the cartoon twenty years later, though… good lord, it was bad. Really terrible.
Similarly, obviously Thro’ The Wall won’t exactly stack up to Crysis, but after the previous post I thought I’d grab an emulator and give it a try again. It really is basic (in BASIC, ahahahaha, sorry), and today probably wouldn’t be in a Top 2000 of games, let alone Top 20. At the time, though, it was the greatest game in the whole world (albeit the only game, but never mind). How to weigh that up against photo-realistic graphics, strong storylines or deep gameplay?